Only a qualified practitioner may deny a claim or prescription
An insurer cannot deny a medical claim or prescription unless a licensed medical professional makes that decision. No algorithm and no non-clinician can issue a final denial.
No insurer may deny, delay or reduce a claim unless a licensed physician or other qualified practitioner in the same field reviews the case.
Every denial must state the medical reason in writing, the clinical rule used, and the name and license number of the reviewer.
No non-clinician, including an automated system, may issue a final denial of care or of a prescription.
Patients may appeal to an independent review panel whose decision binds the insurer.
Enforcement and penalties
Enforced by state insurance commissioners, the Department of Labor for employer plans, and the Department of Health and Human Services.
Criminal: an insurer's responsible officers who knowingly issue an unqualified denial that causes serious harm face fines and up to 10 years in prison.
Civil: fines per denial, scaled to the insurer's annual premium income and indexed to inflation.
Remedy: patients may sue for the full cost of denied care, damages and attorney fees.
Why
Insurance clerks and software should not decide whether a sick person gets treatment. A qualified doctor should make that call, and the patient should see the reason in writing.
Bills already in Congress
Improving Seniors' Timely Access to Care Act119th Congress (2025-2026), H.R. 3514 / S. 1816Speeds up prior authorization decisions in Medicare Advantage. It does not require a qualified practitioner for every denial, so it falls short.
Links go to the bill or law on Congress.gov or GovInfo, or to a Congress.gov search by its name.
Start a petition
A petition shows how many people want this. Copy the text, start a petition, paste it in, and share the petition link.
I am your constituent, and I vote. Please support a law that bars insurers from denying care or prescriptions unless a qualified medical professional reviews the case.
Only a qualified practitioner may deny a claim or prescription. An insurer cannot deny a medical claim or prescription unless a licensed medical professional makes that decision. No algorithm and no non-clinician can issue a final denial.
The law I am asking for would do the following:
No insurer may deny, delay or reduce a claim unless a licensed physician or other qualified practitioner in the same field reviews the case.
Every denial must state the medical reason in writing, the clinical rule used, and the name and license number of the reviewer.
No non-clinician, including an automated system, may issue a final denial of care or of a prescription.
Patients may appeal to an independent review panel whose decision binds the insurer.
It must have teeth:
Enforced by state insurance commissioners, the Department of Labor for employer plans, and the Department of Health and Human Services.
Criminal: an insurer's responsible officers who knowingly issue an unqualified denial that causes serious harm face fines and up to 10 years in prison.
Civil: fines per denial, scaled to the insurer's annual premium income and indexed to inflation.
Remedy: patients may sue for the full cost of denied care, damages and attorney fees.
Please tell me in writing whether you will introduce, cosponsor or vote for this, and if not, why not.