Protect code as speech, and make AI firms pay for stolen IP
Writing and publishing computer code is protected speech under the First Amendment. AI companies that train on stolen intellectual property must pay the owners back.
Writing and publishing computer code is protected speech, and this law codifies that right with a legal remedy.
A person sued or charged over code they wrote may bring a claim for damages and recourse in federal court.
AI companies must license or pay for copyrighted and other intellectual property used in training, and must keep a record of every source.
An AI firm that trains on stolen intellectual property must pay the owner the greater of actual damages or the profit earned, and must delete the stolen data.
Enforcement and penalties
Enforced by the U.S. Copyright Office, the Department of Justice for criminal cases, and federal courts for civil suits.
Criminal: knowingly training an AI model on stolen intellectual property for profit is a felony, with fines and up to 10 years in prison for responsible officers.
Civil: statutory damages per work, scaled to the firm's revenue and indexed to inflation, plus deletion of the model's tainted data.
Remedy: owners may sue for damages, profits and attorney fees, and a person charged over code may sue for recourse.
Why
Code is a form of speech, and creators deserve pay when their work trains a company's product. Without this rule, large AI firms take creative work without paying for it.
Bills already in Congress
Generative AI Copyright Disclosure Act118th Congress (2023-2024), H.R. 7913Requires AI firms to file notice of copyrighted training data. It does not require payment or punish theft, so it falls short.
Links go to the bill or law on Congress.gov or GovInfo, or to a Congress.gov search by its name.
Start a petition
A petition shows how many people want this. Copy the text, start a petition, paste it in, and share the petition link.
I am your constituent, and I vote. Please support a law that protects computer code as speech and requires AI companies to pay for the intellectual property they train on.
Protect code as speech, and make AI firms pay for stolen IP. Writing and publishing computer code is protected speech under the First Amendment. AI companies that train on stolen intellectual property must pay the owners back.
The law I am asking for would do the following:
Writing and publishing computer code is protected speech, and this law codifies that right with a legal remedy.
A person sued or charged over code they wrote may bring a claim for damages and recourse in federal court.
AI companies must license or pay for copyrighted and other intellectual property used in training, and must keep a record of every source.
An AI firm that trains on stolen intellectual property must pay the owner the greater of actual damages or the profit earned, and must delete the stolen data.
It must have teeth:
Enforced by the U.S. Copyright Office, the Department of Justice for criminal cases, and federal courts for civil suits.
Criminal: knowingly training an AI model on stolen intellectual property for profit is a felony, with fines and up to 10 years in prison for responsible officers.
Civil: statutory damages per work, scaled to the firm's revenue and indexed to inflation, plus deletion of the model's tainted data.
Remedy: owners may sue for damages, profits and attorney fees, and a person charged over code may sue for recourse.
Please tell me in writing whether you will introduce, cosponsor or vote for this, and if not, why not.