Commentary networks cannot be labeled news or journalism
A news brand whose main content is commentary may not call itself news or journalism. A bipartisan panel reviews news registrations each year, and only an act of Congress can remove one.
A news brand whose main content is opinion or commentary may not describe itself as news or journalism.
Each news brand must register, and its registration is reviewed every year by a nonpartisan third party.
A bipartisan committee of Congress distributes any public revenue collected from registered news agencies equally among them.
A news registration may be removed only by an act of Congress, passed by a recorded vote.
Enforcement and penalties
Enforced by the Federal Trade Commission for labeling claims, and by the bipartisan committee for registration reviews.
Criminal: a brand that knowingly uses the news label for commentary, or hides its commentary status, faces fines and up to 1 year in prison for its officers.
Civil: fines scaled to the brand's annual revenue, indexed to inflation, and loss of news registration.
Remedy: viewers and rival outlets may sue for an injunction, with attorney fees paid by the brand.
Why
Opinion shows dress themselves up as news and borrow the trust that real reporting earned. Readers deserve to know which is which.
Bills already in Congress
No bill in Congress does this yet. The text on this page is the proposal.
Start a petition
A petition shows how many people want this. Copy the text, start a petition, paste it in, and share the petition link.
I am your constituent, and I vote. Please support a law that keeps commentary networks from calling themselves news or journalism.
Commentary networks cannot be labeled news or journalism. A news brand whose main content is commentary may not call itself news or journalism. A bipartisan panel reviews news registrations each year, and only an act of Congress can remove one.
The law I am asking for would do the following:
A news brand whose main content is opinion or commentary may not describe itself as news or journalism.
Each news brand must register, and its registration is reviewed every year by a nonpartisan third party.
A bipartisan committee of Congress distributes any public revenue collected from registered news agencies equally among them.
A news registration may be removed only by an act of Congress, passed by a recorded vote.
It must have teeth:
Enforced by the Federal Trade Commission for labeling claims, and by the bipartisan committee for registration reviews.
Criminal: a brand that knowingly uses the news label for commentary, or hides its commentary status, faces fines and up to 1 year in prison for its officers.
Civil: fines scaled to the brand's annual revenue, indexed to inflation, and loss of news registration.
Remedy: viewers and rival outlets may sue for an injunction, with attorney fees paid by the brand.
Please tell me in writing whether you will introduce, cosponsor or vote for this, and if not, why not.